What happened to the organic results Google?

By : Administrator
Published 22nd September 2015 |
Read latest comment - 2nd October 2015

Anyone spot anything missing from this picture?

Above the Fold

Builders Warwick is a standard search I use when doing some search engine testing, and the above image shows the results above the fold (ie before you need to start scrolling) on a standard screen. It is an anonymous search, opposed to the personalised results you may see, depending if you are logged into a Google account, had a recent Google cookie etc.

Google is very vocal about the user experience and limiting the number of adverts above the fold. Bit it seems it doesn't follow it's own rules though, as all you can see in the above example is sponsor ad's, or Google Adwords results to be more precise.

The map you can see is part of the new layout for the Google local listings (or map listings, or whatever they are called these days), but you still need to scroll to see any links for them, plus they have now had their phone numbers removed, which a lot of SEO commentators predict will mean fewer leads for small business owners.

Below the Fold

Finally under the map listings, once you have scrolled, you get to the organic listings.

You can then see 4 organic listings at the bottom of the page. In this example, Yell gets the top spot, with mybuilder getting spots 2 and 3.

Conclusion

You probably get enough emails from SEO peeps promising you the world and guaranteeing you number 1 in Google. Now it looks like Google has another idea, pay for it 

In this example, to generate any real return if you needed to show up for this search term would be to pay for a Google Adwords PPC campaign.

Now this is only 1 search, and depending on how and where you search will dictate the results you will see. Plus Google is continually experimenting with layout and tinkering with the search results. But sometimes I think it would be nice to return to the good old list of 10 organic results.

Or would it?

What do you think? Has the regular Google upheaval and tweaking of the search results over the last couple of years impacted the number of leads from Google, or the way you conduct marketing? If so was it for the better or worse?

Maybe it has improved your marketing and ROI, or has it caused you continual confusion and headaches?

As a user, do you like the new Google layout, or do you think there are too many PPC adverts?


Steve Richardson
Gaffer of My Local Services
My Local Services | Me on LinkedIn
Comments

Hi Steve,

Here is my take on the SERPS since the latest algo update:

1. Most of the results that you seeing now are either personalised or geo-targeted when browsing privately - this is to do with location servers from which the data is being pulled from.

2. The phone numbers are listed under the map results for the top 3 listings featured on the map.

3. From an SEO standpoint, the key for us in being able to get our clients featured on that map & although that real estate seems to be growing smaller by the day, it is still an area that continues to drive significant traffic numbers.

4. YES! there are far too many ads above the fold but what is still significant is that the click through rates for PPC hasn't gone up dramatically since the new SERPS format has been rolled out.

My guess is that this new format is being trialed particularly in advance of the Christmas season to entice more PPC customers when ad spending really does hit the proverbial roof and is therefore likely to stay at least in the short term.

Darryl...


Darryl Antonio
Digitalhound
Digitalhound Ltd | Digital Marketing Services

My guess is that this new format is being trialed particularly in advance of the Christmas season to entice more PPC customers when ad spending really does hit the proverbial roof and is therefore likely to stay at least in the short term.

Darryl...”

 

What a beautifully cynical point of view, I bet you are 100% right Digital Hound!


Angela
My views & opinions are my own

Hi Angela,

Didn't mean to come across as being wholly cynical although Christmas seems to start earlier every year - Mince pies were available in our local Co-Op from the 1st week in September!

Being a digital marketing agency though, we're constantly having to adapt, to offer our clients the best current advice as well as tailor our ranking and marketing strategies to coincide with and take full advantage of seasonal fluctuations in the SERPS.

Darryl...


Darryl Antonio
Digitalhound
Digitalhound Ltd | Digital Marketing Services

I personally purposely avoid clicking on any results with ad next to them when I Google, just on principle.


This Thread is now closed for comments